The Differences Slavery Made: A Close Analysis of Two American Communities
Chambersburg Valley Spirit, "White Slavery in England," April 18, 1860

Summary

The article tacitly acknowledges that slavery, as a system of labor, is unfair, yet, Northern Democratic editors contend that the American form of bondage is not as bad as that in England where white workers, they argue, are forced to endure even worse conditions than in the South.

EXCERPT:

"Here are facts which should admonish the professed humanitarians of England to look to their own deplorable system of slavery, and not meddle with our more humane institutions. No slavery in our Southern States equals the cruel servitude imposed by them upon their weak, helpless and distressed white laborers."

Full-text web version of newspaper

Points of Analysis to this Data:

"In the first half of 1860 Democratic editors in Franklin County emphasized slavery's compatibility with the Northern economy and society and Northern complicity in the South's institution."


Citation: Key = E074
Historiography Tools