The Differences Slavery Made: A Close Analysis of Two American Communities

Slaveholders and Agricultural Productivity

In corn and wheat production per acre there was relative equality among most slaveholders and nonslaveholders. For those few farms with the highest numbers of slaves, however, slavery enabled much higher rates of productivity.

Number of Slaves Wheat Production Average production Number of
per acre in bushels by farm cases
0 slaves 1.4 163 236
1 slave 1.2 246 32
2 - 5 slaves 1.8 308 57
6 - 10 slaves 1.8 385 36
11 - 20 slaves 1.4 494 43
21 - 30 slaves 1.5 500 1
31+ slaves 3.6 1500 1
Corn Production Average production Number of
per acre in bushels by farm cases
0 slaves 3.5 371 236
1 slave 2.9 557 32
2 - 5 slaves 4.3 670 57
6 - 10 slaves 3.2 707 36
11 - 20 slaves 3.4 1192 43
21 - 30 slaves 1.8 600 1
31+ slaves 4.8 2000 1
Swine Production Average production Number of
per acre by farm cases
0 slaves 0.22 18.4 236
1 slave 0.17 22.4 32
2 - 5 slaves 0.18 22.9 57
6 - 10 slaves 0.12 23.6 36
11 - 20 slaves 0.12 37.3 43
21 - 30 slaves 0.09 29.0 1
31+ slaves 0.48 200.0 1
Cows Production Average production Number of
per acre by farm cases
0 slaves 0.04 3.7 236
1 slave 0.05 4.3 32
2 - 5 slaves 0.04 5.0 57
6 - 10 slaves 0.03 5.9 36
11 - 20 slaves 0.02 7.4 43
21 - 30 slaves 0.03 9.0 1
31+ slaves 0.02 9.0 1



The data are based on the GIS of Augusta and Franklin households--maps are derived from a D. H. Davison map of Franklin County, published in 1858, and a Jedediah Hotchkiss map of Augusta County, published in 1870, and based on surveys completed "during the war." The maps have been georeferenced at the Virginia Center for Digital History, using ESRI Arc Info to produce a Geographic Information Systems map and database of households based on U.S. census data from the population, agricultural, and slaveowners' schedules.

Edward L. Ayers and William G. Thomas, III
Slaveholders and Agricultural Productivity
2001.

Points of Analysis to this Data:

"Slaveholders in Augusta did not monopolize the best soil nor did they crowd out nonslaveholders or small slaveholders."

"The richest farm households in Augusta, however, had a high correlation with relatively high wheat production and low corn production, and slavery enabled even greater success on these farms."

"The visible differences that slavery made in the arrangement of the landscape were apparent to many observers, but Northerners and Southerners interpreted them differently. Northerners focused on land value per acre and Southerners on the dollar value of their crops."


Citation: Key = E145
Historiography Tools