The Differences Slavery Made: A Close Analysis of Two American Communities

Newspaper Article Reprints by Region

New York supplied the most articles for reprinting for both Augusta and Franklin editors. The Augusta newspapers relied heavily on Richmond for news stories. Other Southern cities' papers, such as the Charleston Mercury for example, supplied only a handful of stories to these editors. In the case of Charleston, Staunton's Whig editor reprinted just six stories and Chambersburg's editors also picked up six stories total.

Place Rep. Vindicator Staunton Spectator Franklin Repository Valley Spirit
Southern Origin Totals 73 156 72 73
Richmond Totals 32 61 23 17
Baltimore Totals 2 13 17 9
Louisville Totals 0 0 4 13
Lynchburg Totals 4 13 0 0
Northern Origin Totals 64 106 180 308
New York Totals 47 77 57 159
Philadelphia Totals 2 8 31 28
Harrisburg Totals 0 0 15 35
Cincinnati Totals 0 6 2 11



Data are derived from Katherine Pierce, "Networks of Disunion" (unpublished paper). Pierce surveyed 1,100 newspaper articles from the Valley of the Shadow Project between 1857 and 1865 in all four of the project's newspapers.

Edward L. Ayers and William G. Thomas, III
Newspaper Article Reprints by Region
2001

Points of Analysis to this Data:

"Newspapers in Franklin were little different from those in Augusta, but the orientation of the Repository and Transcript as the lead Republican paper set the county apart from its neighbors and from those in the South."

"Staunton newspapers bore visual and textual markings of slavery, as they regularly contained ads for runaway slaves, slave agents, and slave sales."

"The Chambersburg newspapers sold a greater range of products than their counterparts in Staunton, and businesses there faced greater competition as well."


Citation: Key = E170
Historiography Tools