The Differences Slavery Made: A Close Analysis of Two American Communities

Land Values in Augusta and Franklin Counties

Franklin farms were more intensely cultivated, and held a much higher average value per acre of improved and unimproved land across all soil types. In Augusta the larger the farm size the lower the average value by acre.

Average Farm Values by Acre in Dollars
Augusta Franklin
Mean Median Mean Median
County Average 32.7 30.0 54.3 50.0
Nonslaveholders 31.1 25.4
Slaveholders 35.1 33.1
Best Soil 34.1 30.0 66.8 66.5
Medium Soil 32.0 31.8 45.1 40.0
Worst Soil 18.4 15.0 19.7 12.4
Lowest Farm Value Quintile 21.4 15.0 40.0 20.0
Low-Medium Farm Value Quintile 22.1 21.5 48.2 32.9
Medium Farm Value Quintile 42.7 31.5 50.7 46.1
Medium-High Farm Value Quintile 34.5 34.3 58.7 60.0
High Farm Value Quintile 41.9 40.0 71.9 70.0
Smallest Farm Size Quintile 46.9 30.8 71.7 67.1
Small-Medium Farm Size Quintile 30.4 30.0 50.4 48.0
Medium Farm Size Quintile 30.8 30.0 32.6 30.2
Medium-Large Farm Size Quintile 29.0 30.2 26.4 21.9
Largest Farm Size Quintile 21.8 14.0 10.3 10.3



The data are based on the GIS of Augusta and Franklin households--maps are derived from a D. H. Davison map of Franklin County, published in 1858, and a Jedediah Hotchkiss map of Augusta County, published in 1870, and based on surveys completed "during the war." The maps have been georeferenced at the Virginia Center for Digital History, using ESRI Arc Info to produce a Geographic Information Systems map and database of households based on U.S. census data from the population, agricultural, and slaveowners' schedules.

Edward L. Ayers and William G. Thomas, III
Land Values in Augusta and Franklin Counties
2001.

Points of Analysis to this Data:

"Slaveholders in Augusta did not monopolize the best soil nor did they crowd out nonslaveholders or small slaveholders."

"The visible differences that slavery made in the arrangement of the landscape were apparent to many observers, but Northerners and Southerners interpreted them differently. Northerners focused on land value per acre and Southerners on the dollar value of their crops."


Citation: Key = E132
Historiography Tools